Commands are an integral part of a language, (at least I know they are in English and in Spanish), which means there are many ways teachers to create activities around commands that have a focus on communication and not on grammar rules.
Below is an activity that will keep the students engaged while focusing on meaning. You can tell students to write informal or formal commands. Both will work fine with the assignment.
1. Prepare for the activity by writing a list of How To topics. I've included mine for you to use or for help give you ideas.
A - How to plan a trip to Hawaii.
B - How to plass Calculus with an 'A'
C - How to impress your boyfriend/girlfriend
D - How to convince a police officer not to give you a speeding ticket
E - How to become a millionaire
F - How to earn/save money for college
G - How to lose weight
H - How to win a marathon
I - How to write a novel
J - How to throw the best party of the year
K - How to avoid/discourage telemarketers
L - How to be a great friend
M - How to make someone smile
N - How to succeed at your job interview
O - How to learn a 2nd language
2. Model the activity. Ask the students (in your TL) to name suggestion they would give to their friend to tell him/her how to get an "A" in your class.
3. Tell students to find a partner. Each group randomly chooses one of the cards A-O listed above.
4. Give the students a large sheet of paper, (I have a roll of white butcher paper that I use for activities like this), and a marker. Allow 8-10 minutes for students to write 6 commands to tell someone How To do whatever is listed on their notecard. Then students hang the papers on the walls.
5. With their partner, students write A-O on a paper. Read the lists on the papers and decide for what the commands are written. Write answers in Spanish.
6. Switch papers with another group to go over the answers.
Having groups of 2 helped to keep all students engaged. The one part of the activity that I wasn't pleased with was when we went over the answers. I felt as if I were losing some of the students' attention. I'm still trying to decide how to improve that part of the activity.
A variation of the above activity is to tell the students to write their lists on an 8 1/2 x 11" paper instead of a poster size paper. Then list the HOW TO categories on the board. Read one of the commands that the students wrote and students decide for which category the command was written.
Thank you so much for all of your wonderful ideas! While I don't normally comment on your posts, I have benefited from every one that I have read and I have learned a lot from you. You create amazing activities and I sincerely appreciate the time and effort that you take to share your ideas!!!
ReplyDeleteThank you for your kind words Josh!
DeleteI'm glad to hear that the activities are beneficial to you.
I love all the ideas on topics!! I know this is an old post, but thought I could add- You had mentioned the engagement at the end. I have noticed that students of all ages like to 'guess"........... what if the students wrote their commands on a piece of paper (leaving off the topic itself) and the class had to guess what their topic was after listening to their commands? Might be a way to switch it up.
ReplyDeleteHi Amanda!
DeleteThanks for leaving a comment. If I understand correctly what you suggested, it is the same thing as #6 above in the explanation. I give the students the topics but students do not see what other groups have. Then, for #6, they rotate around the room and read the commands and guess the topic.
If you have more ideas for commands, I'd love to hear them.
Cynthia
Do you have any suggestions on providing input with commands? I'm struggling! I plan to use something like what you've posted here once they're ready to produce!
ReplyDeleteI completely understand. It seems that commands don't come as easily to some students as other things. One thing that seems to help is to expose them to commands everyday in your regular classroom chat - which you are already probably doing. Sometimes I will stop and say,¿Did I say "sacan los libros" or "saquen los libros" or "Escriban las respuestas...Why did I say Escriban and not Escriben? I ask them those questions long before I do the above activity.
DeleteAnother thing I do is tell a story (it's a made up one that I have a cat that likes to hunt mice and birds but doesn't eat them and then drops them on the front porch of my neighbor) and students have to tell me what to do to solve this problem. I write their suggestions on the board as they respond. Granted, most of them at that point are not saying it correctly, but I don't point that out, but rather write it correctly. None of those things is guaranteed to help them always use commands correctly, but they DO HAVE AN IMPACT. Sometimes I'm want to make that impact happen sooner, but I've found that trying to do that isn't the best use of my time.
One more idea, write a story and then YOU write several options for what you could say to a person to solve the problem. All of the choices you write will be in command form so that gives them A LOT of input on commands. Keep the focus on meaning and "solving the problem" and eventual---l---y, they will start producing it, but with many errors scattered throughout.
If only we had more time with our students to provide CI!!!